The Madrasah Institution in the Safavid and Ottoman Periods: A Comparative Study of the Administrative, Financial, and Scholarly Structures of Madrasahs

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Assistant Professor, Department of History Education, Farhangian University, Tehran, Iran

10.22034/chs.2026.585539.1184
Abstract
Despite their common educational and religious foundations, the madrasah institution in the Safavid and Ottoman states developed distinct forms of organization within two different political and administrative structures. Employing a historical research method and a comparative approach, this study examines and compares the madrasah institution along four dimensions: methods of financial provision, administrative structure and supervision, pathways of scholarly advancement, and the function of the madrasah within the governmental structure. The study is based on an analysis of historical sources and quantitative data extracted from Ottoman biographical sources. The findings indicate that Ottoman madrasahs were organized within a centralized structural framework and maintained close connections with the administrative system and governmental offices, whereas Safavid madrasahs were based on a decentralized pattern that relied on the scholarly standing of teachers and master–disciple relationship and did not follow the centralized Ottoman administrative system. These differences demonstrate that the organization of the madrasah institution in the two states reflected the manner in which the governments interacted with religious education contributing to the emergence of two distinct patterns of religious educational organization in the premodern Islamic world.

Keywords


 
Abadi, Mehdi (2010), “Avamel-e Mo'asser bar Gostaresh-e Madāres dar Ghalamro-ye Osmani (Dore-ye Classic: Sadeh-haye 8–10 Hejri)” (Factors Influencing the Expansion of Schools in the Ottoman Territories during the Classical Period: The 8th–10th Centuries AH), Pazhuheshname-ye Tarikh va Tamaddon-e Eslami (Journal of Islamic History and Civilization), 43(1), 81–108.
Abadi, Mehdi, and Seyyed Mohammad Reza Hosseini (2017), “Modarresiyan-e Osmani va Bazyaft-e Nofooz-e Siyasi-ye Anha dar Ahd-e Morad-e Dovvom” (Ottoman Mudarrises and the Recovery of Their Political Influence during the Reign of Murad II), Pazhuheshname-ye Tarikh-e Eslam (Journal of Islamic History), 7(26), 79–101.
Açıkel, Ali (2023), “Tokat Hoca Behzad Camii ve Muallimhanesi Vakıfları”, Cumhuriyet Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 47 (1), 1-9.
Afandi, Mirza Abdollah (2010), Riyaz al-Olama va Hiyaz al-Fozala (The Gardens of Scholars and the Enclosures of Virtuous Men), translated by Mohammad Bagher Saedi, Mashhad: Astan Quds Razavi Publications.
Afushta'i Natanzī, Mahmud ibn Hedayatollah (1994), Neqavat al-Asar fi Zekr al-Akhyar (The Finest Accounts of the Notables), Tehran: Elmi va Farhangi Publications.
Akbash, Ayla (2014), “Functions of ‘Madrasas’ in the Ottoman Period”, Khazar Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, 17 (2), Article 5.
Akman, Ekrem (2026), “Bir mirin zihin dünyası: Şirvan miri Zeynel Bey’in Küfre medresesi vakfiyesi”, İçtimaiyat, 10 (1), 31-50.
Al-Aydini, Ali ibn Bali (2010), Al-Aqd al-Manzum fi Zikr Afazil al-Rum (Zayl al-Shaqa'iq al-Nu'maniyya fi Ulama al-Dawla al-Uthmaniyya) (The Well-Ordered Necklace on the Eminent Scholars of Rum: A Supplement to The Anemones of the Ottoman Scholars), Tehran: Library, Museum and Documentation Center of the Islamic Consultative Assembly.
Altay, Bora, Bulut, Mehmet (2024), “An Analysis of Cash Waqf Institutions and Real Wages in Ottoman Rumelia, 1500–1914”, ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance, 16 (1), 71–83.
Altuntaş, Mustafa Celil (2013), “Osmanlı Daru’l Hadis Medreselerindeki Görev Dağılımı”, Anadolu’nun İslamlaşma Sürecinde Dâru’l-Hadisler, Çankırı, Türkiye.
Ashkuri, Seyyed Sadeq (2008), Asnad-e Moqufat-e Esfahan (Documents of Endowments in Isfahan), under the supervision of the General Department of Endowments and Charitable Affairs of Isfahan, Qom: Majma-e Zakhayer-e Eslami.
Bakhshi Ostad, Musa al-Reza (2013), Jaygah-e Madrese dar Asr-e Safavi (The Position of Schools in the Safavid Period), Tehran: Yasin Noor Publications.
Bakhshi Ostad, Musa al-Reza, and Nezhat Ahmadi (2013), “Ta'sir-e Elmi-ye Madāres dar Asr-e Safavi” (The Scholarly Impact of Schools in the Safavid Period), Pazhuheshname-ye Tarikh-e Eslam (Journal of Islamic History), 3(11), 7–27.
Beyazıt, Yasemin (2009), “Osmanlı İlmiyye Bürokrasisinde Şeyhülislâmlığın Değişen Rolü ve Mülâzemet Sistemi (XVI.–XVIII. Yüzyıllar)”, Belleten, 73 (267), 423–442.
Beyazıt, Yasemin (2014), “XVI. Yüzyıl Osmanlı İlmiyye Kanûnnâmeleri ve Medrese Eğitimi”, Belleten, 78 (283), 955–982.
çıkel, Ali (2017), “Niksar Kazası Sinan Bey Vakıfları”, Vakıflar Dergisi, 48, 17-33.
Dorsun, Davud (2002), Din va Siasat dar Dowlat-e Osmani (Religion and Politics in the Ottoman State), translated by Mansoureh Hosseini and Davud Vafaei, Tehran: Organization for Printing and Publishing of the Library, Museum and Documentation Center.
Efendi, Ahmed ibn Mustafa Tashkoprizadeh (n.d.), Al-Shaqa'iq al-Nu'maniyya fi Ulama al-Dawla al-Uthmaniyya (The Anemones of Ottoman Scholars), Istanbul: Dar al-Sa'ada.
Ehsanoglu, Ekmeleddin (2007), “Madāres-e Emperaturi-ye Osmani” (The Schools of the Ottoman Empire), translated by Mehdi Abadi, Majalle-ye Tarikh-e Eslam (Journal of Islamic History), 8(29), 149–174.
Engin, Sezai (2017), “Osmanlı Dönemi Medreselerinde Hadis Eğitimine Entelektüel Bir Katkı: Şerh ve Hâşiye Yazıcılığı”, Marife, 17 (2), 257-269.
Eyestquitz, Norman (1998), Emperaturi-ye Osmani va Sonnat-e Eslami (The Ottoman Empire and Islamic Tradition), translated by Ahmad Tavakoli, Tehran: Peykan Publications.
Faroghi, Suraiya (1973), “Social mobility and the Ottoman ulema in the late sixteenth century”, International Journal of Middle East Studies, 4 (2), 204-218.
Fındıklı, Burhan (2022), “Rethinking Ancient Centers of Higher Learning: madrasa in a comparative-historical perspective”, British Journal of Educational Studies, 70 (2), 129-144.
Gemici, Nurettin (2019), “Education system and educational institutions in the Ottoman Empire”, Akademik Bakış Dergisi, 72, 48–56.
Genç, Safinur (2026), “Osmanlı Medreseleri: Vakıf, Müfredat ve Bürokrasi Temelli Bir Yükseköğretim Modeli”, İhya Uluslararası İslam Araştırmaları Dergisi, 12 (2), 917-944.
Hızlı, Mefail (2004), “Anadolu’daki Osmanlı Medreseleri: Bir İcmal”, Türkiye Araştırmaları Literatür Dergisi, 2 (4), 371-409.
İnalcık, Halil (1973), The Ottoman Empire: The Classical Age 1300–1600, Translated by Norman Itzkowitz & Colin Imber, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.
Jafarian, Rasul (2000), Safaviyeh dar Arse-ye Din, Farhang va Siasat (The Safavids in the Fields of Religion, Culture, and Politics), Qom: Research Institute of Hawza and University.
Jazayeri, Seyyed Ne'matollah (n.d.), Al-Anvar al-Nu'maniyya (The Nu'manian Lights), Beirut: Al-A'lami Institute for Publications.
Kampfer, Engelbert (1981), Safarname-ye Kampfer (Kaempfer's Travelogue), translated by Kikavus Jahandari, Tehran: Kharazmi Publications.
Khatunabadi, Abdolhossein (1973), Vaqaye al-Senin va al-A'vam (Chronicle of Years and Events), edited by Mohammad Bagher Behboudi, Tehran: Eslami Bookshop.
Kidu, Akram (2016), Nahad-e Sheykh al-Eslami dar Dowlat-e Osmani (The Institution of the Sheikh al-Islam in the Ottoman State), translated by Seyyed Mohammad Reza Mostafavinia and Hassan Hazrati, Tehran: Neday-e Tarikh.
Majlesi, Mohammad Bagher (2024), Behar al-Anvar al-Jame'a le-Dorar Akhbar al-A'emmat al-Athar (Oceans of Lights: A Collection of Pearls from the Reports of the Immaculate Imams), Beirut: Al-Wafa Foundation.
Mirza Samia (1999), Tazkere-ye Moluk (The Memoirs of the Kings), edited by Mohammad Dabir-Siaqi, Tehran: Amir Kabir Publications.
Nasrabadi, Mirza Mohammad Taher (1982), Tazkere-ye Nasrabadi (The Nasrabadi Biographical Anthology), edited by Vahid Dastgerdi, Tehran: Foroughi Bookshop.
Olearius, Adam (1990), Safarname-ye Olearius (Olearius's Travelogue), translated by Hossein Kordbacheh, Tehran: Ketab Baraye Hameh Publications.
Ozon Charshili, Hakkı Ismail (1998), Tarikh-e Osmani (The History of the Ottoman Empire), translated by Iraj Nobakht, Tehran: Keyhan Publications.
Sharden, Jean (1951), Safarname-ye Bakhsh-e Esfahan (Travelogue of the Isfahan Section), translated by Hossein Arizi, n.p.: Rah-e Nejat Printing House.
Sharden, Jean (1959), Siyahatname-ye Sharden (Chardin's Travelogue), translated by Mohammad Abbasi, Tehran: Amir Kabir Publications.
Shushtari, Seyyed Nourallah (1997), Majales al-Mo'menin (The Assemblies of the Believers), Tehran: Eslami Bookshop.
Tabrizi, Mohammad Zaman (1994), Fara'ed al-Fava'ed dar Ahval-e Masajed va Madāres (The Precious Benefits concerning the Conditions of Mosques and Schools), compiled by Rasul Jafarian, Tehran: Daftar-e Nashr-e Mirاث-e Maktub.
Tuğrul, Mehmet (2025), “Osmanlı’da Eğitimin Finansmanı: 18. Yüzyıl Rumelisinde Medrese Sisteminin Sürdürülmesinde Para Vakıflarının Rolü”, Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Dergisi, 12 (2), 612-643.
Unan, Fahri (1999), “Osmanlılarda Medrese Eğitimi”, Yeni Türkiye, 5, 140–160, Ankara: Yeni Türkiye Yayınları.
Valah Esfahani, Mohammad Yousef (1993), Khold-e Barin (The Eternal Paradise), edited by Mir Hashem Mohaddes, Tehran: Dr. Mahmoud Afshar Endowment Foundation.
Vaqfname-ye Madrese-ye Emamiye-ye Esfahan (Endowment Deed of the Emamiyeh School of Isfahan), No. 15181, Tehran: Library of the Islamic Consultative Assembly.
Yılmaz, Harun (2019), “Medrese Geleneğinde Yenilik ve Kurumsallaşma: XV. ve XVI. Yüzyıl Osmanlı Medreseleri”, Osmanlı Medreseleri: Eğitim, Yönetim ve Finans, edited by Fuat Aydın, Mahmut Zengin, Kübra Cevherli, and Yunus Kaymaz, İstanbul: Mahya Yayıncılık, 327-337.
Volume 18, Issue 69 - Serial Number 69
Autumn 2026
Autumn 2026
Pages 97-124

  • Receive Date 07 June 2026
  • Revise Date 14 August 2026
  • Accept Date 21 September 2026
  • Publish Date 23 October 2026