The Evolution of Historical Representation in Imagery: A Systematic Study of Visual Content in Iranian History Textbooks during the Qajar and Pahlavi Eras (1897–1941)

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Ph.D. Student of History, Faculty of Law and Social Sciences, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran.

Abstract
The present study aims to investigate the discursive mechanisms of power and knowledge in the images of Iranian history textbooks, and conducts a statistical and content analysis of 2008 images from 76 history textbooks from the Qajar and Reza Shah periods. The data were obtained through systematic and documented collection from reliable sources, including the Ayatollah Boroujerdi Digital Library and the Agha Bozorg database. The theoretical framework of the study is based on the integration of Foucault's thought on discourse and regimes of truth drawing on Krippendorff's quantitative content analysis model with an interdisciplinary approach. The findings show that the images in textbooks were not a neutral representation of history, but a tool for producing and reproducing legitimate historical knowledge within the framework of the power order. In the Qajar period, representations focused more on the glory of the monarchy and the continuity of tradition, while in the Reza Shah period, the image served the discourse of the modern state, nationalism, and cultural discipline. By combining statistical and discursive analysis, this research offers a new perspective for understanding power relations, historical memory, and visual education in Iran.

Keywords


Akbari, Mohammad Ali (2014), Genealogy of the New Iranian Identity (Qajar and First Pahlavi Era), 2nd edition, Tehran: Elmi va Farhangi.
 Akbari, Mohammad Ali and Shakourghahari, Masoumeh (2012), Cultural Aspects of Iranianness in the Textbooks of the First Pahlavi Era (History, Geography and Persian Literature Books), Miskaveh, 7(23), 7-32.
Amiri, Hassan and Ebrahimzadeh, Eissa (2010), Depicting Iranian Identity in the Textbooks of Persian Literature and History of Iranian Secondary Schools from (1941 to 1965), Master’s Thesis, Shahid Beheshti University.
Askarani, Mohammad Reza (2010), Pathology of History Teaching in the Iranian Education System: A Case Study from the Qajar Era to the End of Reza Shah’s Period, Cultural History Studies, 2(5).
Bigdalo, Reza and Mursali, Soraya (2017), Representation of Racial Identity in History Textbooks of Elementary and High Schools in the First Pahlavi Period, Cultural History Studies (Research Journal of the Iranian History Association), 9(34), 1-24.
Chaput, C. (2009), "Regimes of truth, disciplined bodies, secured populations: an overview of Michel Foucault", Science Fiction Film & Television, 2(1), 91-104.
Faramarzi, Azam, Kalhor, Mohammad and Khodari Zadeh, Ali Akbar (2021), Promoting National Doctrines and Concepts in the Content of History Textbooks in the Second Pahlavi Era: Applying Ruth Wedak’s Theory of Historical Discourse Analysis, Historical Research, 13(4), 77-92.
Foucault, M. (1971), “Orders of discourse”, Social science information, 10(2), 7-30.
Foucault, M. (2020), “Power/knowledge”, in The new social theory reader, London: Routledge, 73-79.
Hamedi, Zahra (2013), Pathology of History Textbook Compilation and Educational Issues in the Reza Shah Era, Cultural History Studies, 17, 21-40.
Jafarian, Rasoul (2024), Analysis and Interpretation of the Text of Iranian History, Preliminary Course (1911 CE) by Agha Sheikh Abdol Razzaq Qomi Problem Solver (d. 1911 CE), Aineh Pahoejosh, 35(206), 617-756.
Karimi, Amir (2024a), Military-authoritarian functions of history education in Nazi Germany and Iran during the period of Reza Shah: a comparative study, Quarterly of Police Historical Studies, 11(42), 83-104.
Karimi, Amir (2025a), Teaching History in Schools: Challenges and Solutions from the Perspective of Iranian Publications (1958-1968), Quarterly journal of research in social studies education, 7(2), 67-84.
Karimi, Amir (2025b), Reza Shah’s Legacy in Pahlavi History Textbooks: A Semiotic Approach to the Representation of Power and Identity, Muṭāli̒āt-i tārīkh-i farhangī, 17(65), 1-36.
Karimi, Amir (2026), Representation of Women in History Textbooks of the Second Pahlavi Period: An Analysis Based on Foucault’s Thoughts, Tahqiqāt-e Tārikh-e Ejtemā’i (Social History Studies), 15(2), 195-233.
Karimi, Amir, Abbas Ghadimi Gaidari and Mohammad Salmasizadeh (2024b), A Comparative Study of the Functions of History Education in Nazi Germany (1933-1945) and Iran during the Reza Shah Pahlavi Period (1925-1941), Master’s Thesis, University of Tabriz.
Khosravanian, Hamidreza and Eissa Ebrahimzadeh (2008), Depicting National (Iranian) Identity in Secondary History Textbooks from 1964-2006, Master’s Thesis, Shahid Beheshti University.
Krippendorff, K. (1989), “Content analysis”, International encyclopedia of communication, 1(1), 403-407.
Krippendorff, K. (2018), Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology, London: Sage publications.
Mollai Tavani, Alireza (2016), The Official Historiographical Discourse of the Pahlavi Period Around Reza Shah, Tehran: Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies.
Mollai Tavani, Alireza (2021), The Challenges of History in Today’s Iran, Tehran: Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies.
Pfohl, S. (2017), “Foucault and the Visual Reconstitution of Criminological Knowledge”, Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Oxford: Oxford Press.
Ruslan, A. (2024), “Analysis of History Textbooks: A Review of Michel Foucault’s Power Relations Theory”, KnE Social Sciences, 344-353.
Saeedi, Hourieh (2000), An Introduction to the Evolution of History Textbooks in Schools from the Dar al-Fonun to the End of the First Pahlavi Period, Contemporary History of Iran, 13-14, 25-62.
Salimi, Hossein (2018), The Romantic Origin of the Nationalist Discourse of the First Pahlavi Period and the Teaching of National Identity in Elementary School Textbooks, Cultural History Studies, 36, 77-104.
Sefat Gol, Mansour (1999), History Writing in Iran from the Dar al-Fonun to the Fall of the Qajar Rule, Enghelab University, 112, 153-196.
Villadsen, K. (2015), “Governmentality: Foucault’s concept for our modern political reasoning”, in Education Policy and Contemporary Theory, London: Routledge, 147-159.
Vojdani, Farzin (2023), The Evolution of Historiography in Contemporary Iran: Education, Nationalism and Culture, translated by Amir Saeed Elahi, Tehran: Parse Book Publishing.
 
Textbooks
Qajar Period Textbooks
Birjandi, Sayyed Mohammad (1919), The History of the Great French Revolution, Sa’adat Library.
Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (1936), A Brief History of Alexander the Great, Bina.
Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (1926), A Brief History of Iran and the World (Fifth and Sixth Grades of Elementary School), Tehran: Haqiqat Printing House.
Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (1926), A Brief History of the World: For the Fifth and Sixth Years of Elementary Schools, Tehran: Iran Library (Hajeb al-Dowleh Timcheh).
Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (1915), A Brief History of the World for the Fifth and Sixth Years of Elementary Schools, Tehran: Sa’adat.
Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (1900), Elementary Course in World History, Vol. 1, Tehran: Bina.
Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (1916), Iranian History as Part of the Fifth- and Sixth-Year Elementary School Curriculum, Tehran: Eqbal.
Foroughi, Mohammad Hossein (1910), A Brief History of the Nations of the East, Bina.
Hakim al-Ilahi Qomshaei, Abd al-Hossein (1916), The Sacred History of Islam: An Account of the Life, Campaigns, and Sayings of the Seal of the Prophets, Tehran: Golbahar Library.
Katozian Tehrani, Mohammad Ali (1913), A Brief History of the Prophets, Tehran: Scientific Library.
Kazeruni, Abolhasan (1914), Lata’if al-Tawarikh: Comprising the Ancient History of the Chaldeans, Medes, Persians, and Macedonians, for Third- and Fourth-Grade Students.
Lavisse, Ernest (1913), Jamshidi Foundation (General and World History) Textbook, translated by Karim Khan Mo’aven-e Nezam, Tehran: Matba’eh-ye Mirza Ali Asghar.
Motarjem al-Saltaneh, Ali-Khan (1916), The History of Iran: From the Curriculum of the Fifth and Sixth Years of Elementary Schools, Tehran: Eqbal Library.
Mirza Hossein-Khan (1910), The History of Iran: From the Curriculum of the Second Year, Bina.
Mirza Hossein-Khan (1913), The History of Iran: From the Curriculum of the Second Year, Tehran: Mosaddegh Printing House.
Omid, Mirza Hossein-Khan (1926), Omid’s History of Iran: A Third-Year Textbook for the Third and Fourth Years of Iranian Elementary Schools.
Seyyed Ali-Khan (1924), An Illustrated Brief History of the World: For the Fifth and Sixth Grades of Elementary Schools, Tehran: Mahdieh Library (Hajeb al-Dowleh Timcheh).
Tehrani, Mohammad Ali (n.d), A Brief History of the Prophets, Tehran: Elmi Library.
 
Reza Shah Pahlavi Period Textbooks
Farahoodi, Hossein (1936), Course in General History, Vol. 3: For the Third Year of Secondary Schools, Tehran: Matbu’at Company.
Farahpour, Mirza Mahdi-Khan (1929), Farahpour’s General History: For the Sixth Grade of Elementary Schools, Tehran: Scientific Library and Danesh Library (Kermanshah).
Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (1928), A Brief History of Iran and the World for the Fifth and Sixth Grades of Iranian Primary Schools, Tehran: Matba’eh-ye Hosseini.
Khosrowpour, Majmu’eh Amir (1968), A Brief History of Iran and Part of World History for the Fifth and Sixth Years of Elementary Schools, Tehran: Sa’adat Library.
Ramzi, Seyyed Hossein-Khan (1928), An Introductory History of Iran, with an Appendix on the Pahlavi Era: For the Second and Third Years of Schools, Tehran: Islamic Scientific Library and Akhavan Ketabchi.
Shaibani, Abdolhossein, et al. (1939), History for the First Year of Secondary School, Tehran: Majles Printing House.
Yasemi, Gholamreza Rashid (1941), The History of Iran for Teaching in the Fifth and Sixth Years of Elementary School, Tehran: Ketab Publishing Company.
Ministry of Culture (1939), History: First Year of Secondary Schools, Majles Printing House.
Ministry of Culture (1940a), History: Second Year of Secondary Schools, Taban Printing House.
Ministry of Culture (1940b), History: Third Year of Secondary Schools, Bank Melli Iran Printing House.
Motarjem al-Saltaneh Zarrinkalam, Eqbal, Hossein (1968), A Brief History of Iran: For the Third and Fourth Grades of Iranian Primary Schools, Tehran: Eqbal Library.
 
Documents
Minutes of the Meetings of the Supreme Council of Education (Ma’arif) (1922), Session 4, Tehran: Secretariat of the Supreme Council of Education.
Minutes of the Meetings of the Supreme Council of Education (Ma’arif) (1923), Session 28, Tehran: Secretariat of the Supreme Council of Education.
Minutes of the Meetings of the Supreme Council of Education (Ma’arif) (1928), Session 119, Tehran: Secretariat of the Supreme Council of Education.
Minutes of the Meetings of the Supreme Council of Education (Ma’arif) (1937), Session 356, Tehran: Secretariat of the Supreme Council of Education.
Minutes of the Meetings of the Supreme Council of Education (Ma’arif) (1938), Session 374, Tehran: Secretariat of the Supreme Council of Education.
Minutes of the Meetings of the Supreme Council of Culture (1938), Session 383, Tehran: Secretariat of the Supreme Council of Education.
Volume 18, Issue 68 - Serial Number 68
Summer 2026
Summer 2026
Pages 93-134

  • Receive Date 18 December 2025
  • Revise Date 18 July 2026
  • Accept Date 02 August 2026
  • Publish Date 23 July 2026